Update: Igor Vovkovinskiy Does Have Closed Growth Plates, At Least In The Distal Tibia

I wrote the last post a little too fast and never finished the full video on the 60 Minutes website entitled “Walking Tall” about Igor Vovkovinskiy. In the previous post, I had claimed that Igors own doctor is mistaken and wrong about stating that Igor can still grow. We as the height increase researchers and the licensed physician allowed to treat a pituitary giant is wrong in the science.

Now I am even more sure that the doctor was wrong about Igor. Igor can’t grow any taller. HIs height has stooped increasing. HIs tumor might make him wider, and given him a wider face, or hips, or thicker bones, but he should not be getting any taller.

The thing I was wondering about the previous post was whether the doctors had ever taken an X-ray of Igor’s body. Well I at the time did not watch the 2nd half of the 60 minutes video. It seems that they have. around the 9 minute mark the 60 minutes reporter meets Igor’s doctor to look at his leg bones.

You can clearly see that Igor’s lower limbs and the top of his feet has been X-rayed. I spent quite a few minutes to really check the X-ray.

Around 9:07 time, you can get a very clear view of Igor’s left leg. There is no cartilage or growth plates left. There is also no epiphyseal line either. Since the human body is more or less symmetrical, I would say it is reasonable to assume that if we saw the X-ray of his right leg and right feet, we would also find the same thing, no growth plates or epiphyseal lines.

So does this mean that Igor has no growth plates anymore? Not exactly, since in the human body, different areas and specific growth plates ossify at different times in development. I had written before in the past that even though the growth plates in the limbs may be gone, there might still be some cartilage left in the torso, in the vertebrate irregular bones.

If we look at one website MedHelp.com, a medical questions and answers site, we see that we do get sort of answer to our last question. A Dr. Vinod answers someone who calls themselves “shorty”.

Dr Vinod
Jul 12, 2009
To: shorty21841

We can give you the ossification of few of the important bones. It is difficult to write about primary, secondary and the total ossification of all the bones.

Femur:
The 3 epiphyses/growth plates at upper end fuse at 18years
The 1 epiphysis/growth plate at lower end fuse at 20 years

Tibia:
Upper end fuses at 16-18 years
Lower end fuses at 15-17 years

Humerus:
Upper end during 20th year
Lower end at about 16 years

Radius:
Upper end during 18th year
Lower end at 20 years

Take care!

Analysis:
So it does seem that of all the growth plates to go, the distal tibial ones may be one of the most early ones. It could imply then that Igor even at the age of 29 might have still a few cartilage left which might be the reason his doctor has claimed Igor can still grow taller. Maybe due to the difference in rates of growth plate closure, as seen from the chart of different regions above, it might be that igor does have some areas in his body which has been slower in ossifying than others.
If that is the case, then the next million dollar question is, “How is it that igor at the age of 29 could still have growth plate cartilage left?”
If that is not the case, then we can comfortably say that Igor is now past puberty, his growth plates are gone, and he is not getting any taller, and that his doctor is ignorant of how pituitary giantism really works.

2 thoughts on “Update: Igor Vovkovinskiy Does Have Closed Growth Plates, At Least In The Distal Tibia

  1. Tyler DAvis

    I saw the x-ray in the video and it looks like it doesn’t get the whole leg. The lower ankle shows no signs of a visible growth plate but it’s grainy. So there could still be growth in the upper bone and other bones.

    1. admin

      True. I realize that and I considered those issues. The distal tibia growth plates are one of the earliest ones to go. However Igor was around 29 when that video and the X-ray was shown.

Comments are closed.