Monthly Archives: May 2013

Increase Height And Grow Taller Using Sodium Pentosan Polysulfate AKA Pentosan

Something that I am starting to use as a rule of thumb to find possible chemical compounds that can lead to at least a little bit of height increase in adults is that if it seems to have ability to decrease the symptoms of arthritis or osteoarthritis, there is a good chance it would help in improving the physiological function and structure of the articular cartilage in the end of our long bones, like the hip and knees. As a result, it might mean that it makes the cartilage layer thicker, giving us a few millimeters of extra height.

Something I did find which is used in improving knee osteoarthritis is known as sodium pentosan polysulfate. There are just a few of the studies I’ve found which shows its possible clinical uses.

Study #1: Sodium pentosan polysulfate resulted in cartilage improvement in knee osteoarthritis – An open clinical trial

Background

Pentosan polysulfate sodium (pentosan) is a semi-synthetic drug manufactured from beech-wood hemicellulose by sulfate esterification of the xylopyranose hydroxyl groups. From in vitro and animal model studies, pentosan has been proposed as a disease modifying osteoarthritis drug (DMOAD). The objective of this study was to assess the efficacy, safety, and patient satisfaction in patients with mild radiographic knee osteoarthritis (OA) findings and OA-associated symptoms and signs.

Methods

“…Treatment consisted of 6 weekly subcutaneous injections (sc) of pentosan (2 mg/kg). Patients were clinically assessed at entry and 1 to 8, 11, 15, 24 & 52 weeks post treatment.”

Study #2: Pentosan Polysulfate: A Novel Therapy for the Mucopolysaccharidoses

Abstract

Pentosan polysulfate (PPS) is an FDA-approved, oral medication with anti-inflammatory and pro-chondrogenic properties. We have previously shown that animal models of the mucopolysaccharidoses (MPS) exhibit significant inflammatory disease, contributing to cartilage degeneration. Enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) only partly reduced inflammation, and anti-TNF-alpha antibody therapy significantly enhanced clinical and pathological outcomes. Here we describe the use of PPS for the treatment of MPS type VI rats.

I did some research on the references and citations of the 2nd study and it did mention one study published which I think most other height increase researchers would agree makes the Pentosan a very good candidate as another possible chemical compound which has chondrocyte proliferation and eventual height increasing potential. The study is…

Pentosan polysulfate promotes proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation of adulthuman bone marrow-derived mesenchymal precursor cells.

Authors: Ghosh P, Wu J, Shimmon S, Zannettino AC, Gronthos S, Itescu S.

From the conclusions…

“This is the first study to demonstrate that PPS promotes MPC proliferation and chondrogenesis, offering new strategies for cartilage regeneration and repair in osteoarthritic joints.”

Results

Significant MPC proliferation was evident by day 3 at PPS concentrations of 1 to 5 microg/ml (P < 0.01). In the presence of 1 to 10 microg/ml PPS, a 38% reduction in IL-4/IFNgamma-induced MPC apoptosis was observed. In 5-day MMC, 130% stimulation of PG synthesis occurred at 2.5 microg/ml PPS (P < 0.0001), while 5.0 microg/ml PPS achieved maximal stimulation in the 7-day and 10-day cultures (P < 0.05). HA and DS at > or = 5 microg/ml inhibited PG synthesis (P < 0.05) in 5-day MMC. Collagen type II deposition by MMC was significant at > or = 0.5 microg/ml PPS (P < 0.001 to 0.05). In MPC-PPS pellet cultures, more PG, collagen type II but less collagen type I was deposited than in controls. Real-time PCR results were consistent with the protein data. At 5 and 10 microg/ml PPS, MPC osteogenic differentiation was suppressed (P < 0.01).

Interpretation of the Abstract

Just from a small dosage ranging from 2.5-10 micrograms/mL of the PPS, 5 major things happened.

  1. Increase in the adult adipose tissue derived mesenchymal stem cells
  2. Reduction in Interleukin-4 induced MSCs apoptosis
  3. Stimulated more proteoglycan synthesis
  4. Collagen Type II by the stem cells were increased
  5. The PPS also managed to suppress the stem cells from turning into bone cells.

All I can say it that this new compound Sodium Pentosan Polysulfate, aka Pentosan, has some really promising features which would make it good as an additional compound used for the height increase research.

Natural Height Growth Podcast, Episode 10: I Talk About The Research And Science Behind Adult Height Increase Blog

Logo1In this podcast episode I will be speaking alone looking at what is being sold on the AdultHeightIncrease.Blogspot.com blog and seeing how valid the guy is in the research he has been doing. Like so many people in this community including many former and current height increase researchers, he has declined the chance to come on the podcast and have his voice heard.

Since this area of scientific research is so lucrative, it is very hard to find people who would be willing to come on the website to talk about their research and have their voices broadcasted throughout the entire internet space. I understand that we all really care about our privacy and value security and anonymity when we are looking at this issue. Most people reject the opportunity to come on and speak.

He did answer back with all those answers to my questions.

Here is what I can say about the main contributor to the Adult Height Increase blog, Tim.

  • He has been around a very long time, since at least 2007 when he was a contributor to old message boards like the Impartial Height Increase Message Board
  • He has been doing some serious research.
  • He has a few formulas he has made to try to induce height increase even for physically mature adults.
  • No formula that he has developed so far has been consistently successful
  • He has been an active member in many other grow taller forums.

1st, I have to address the fact that I have in a previous post already written about the product sold on the Adult Height Increase blog which is called MONSTER BS FORMULA entitled “Review On MONSTER BS FORMULA Sold By Adult Height Increase Blog”. In that post I was very hesitant to believe that the two part formulation would work.

  • The first part actually does make some sense. To get the bones to theoretically stretch out, you would have to demineralize or remove calcium by stimulating and adding more parathyroid hormone using the PTC-H formula. The thing about the calcitonin I don’t know about since I never did any research on calcitonin.
  • The idea of using a hyperbaric chamber to increase the possible O2 diffusion into the human body for increased cell proliferation would not do any good

These are the emails we have exchanged back and forth…


Hey Tim,

This is Michael from Natural Height Growth. I think you might be on to something and I wanted to pick your brains a little. My research is on going but it seems that you have been at this for at least 3 more years than me. I believe that you are much more knowledgeable on what actually works than me. I want to ask you about your research. would you be interested in explaining your results to the other height increase seekers to listen to my podcast? I don’t view ourselves as competitors since we are both working on the same eventual goal. This thing is too big and complicated for any one person to do. If you are not interested, I understand. Just hoping to hear from you. – Michael


Hello Micheal

I saw your blog and it has quite a lot of information of all presently
available options.  I would be willing to answer your questions here.
I would also be willing to offer you a sample of my formulas for you
to try personally. – Thanks


That is fine.

These are the questions.

  1. Tell me about yourself, age, height, ethnicity, background, education
  2. How long have you been doing the research?
  3. What got you interested in this endeavor?
  4. Have you found a working, consistent formula?
  5. If not, what do you think are the most feasible mixtures or formulations you have created.
  6. What is the active ingredient in PTH-C formula
  7. The study you link to does not show any link between increased O2  and chondrogenesis. How does this step make people taller?
  8. What is the link between NO stimulation and adult height increase?
  9. How does the PTH-C manage to focus on the localized bone area instead of just affecting the entire skeletal structure?

Hello Micheal.

Here are your answers.

Age 37, 185 cm, ethnicity do not want to reveal, knowledge in homeopathy as a special interest due to working with a 60-year-of-experience homeopath doctor as a salesman and co-manufacturer of specialized compounds.

Since 1993.  Began blog in 2005 for international participation. 20 years.

Personal goal to grow taller using a cheaper and easily accessible method.  Never wanted to go for LL surgery.

No. Some brilliant results but mostly failures.  Less than 5% success rate thus far and most trials have indeed failed.

Key to grow taller is to convert bones to a growing state more than anything else, something like LL does creating a cartilaginous space in the hard bones to grow and then stretch it.

Chemically it is plain water but it is powered by substance derived photons such as plants, minerals, salts, etc, which can manipulate the biophotons which is the light emitted by genes when biochemical processes takes place in the nucleus of the cells.  This tampers biophotons to tweak biochemical reactions to attain an effect.

Yes study does not directly show that but I don’t exclusively rely on studies alone but develop and test out new ideas hitherto untested to achieve a breakthrough.  Such brute force methods have produced breakthroughs in the past when a candidate aged 23 grew an inch in just 7 days by overdosing Monster formula. http://www.network54.com/Forum/611972/message/1250401239/Update+8-16+%28Correction%29

Note that hyperbaric therapy is done for just short durations of 60-90 minute sessions only and these studies are based on those but what if your body is under hyper-oxygenation effect for 24 hours in a broken bone state, won’t the body be forced to stimulate cartilage cells to repair, remember body is dynamic. See this study of a short duration hyperbaric therapy on the longitudinal bones of rabbits –  Please read attached PDF.

PTH-C is a problem area, making formula too strong leads to weakening of the skeleton and REDUCTION of height. I tested this by taking standalone.  So it has to be made just right to enable gentle calcium and mineral depletion and making Muscle builder formula very strong to get a powerful and safe effect.   So after many tweaks I arrived at a safer PTH-C formula.  First created was a plain PTH formula later added a calcitonin suppressant. So the idea is making bones “soft”and creating growth using the Muscle builder formula.

Please read more about the Muscle builder formula below – Bone marrow contains mesenchymal stem cells that can build cartilage cells which grow into bones.  One way to stimulate them is to load the blood with very high oxygen content and force feed body tissues with that under  a pressurized oxygen chamber.  This has shown to increase of stem cells by 800% in 40-60 hours of treatment seen in the hyperbaric oxygen treatment which is done for short duration only due to risk of hyperoxemia.

The muscle builder formula accomplishes the same by the oral dose without the use of pressure chambers by alternative mechanism but similar and even more powerful effects.

When I built this formula called Muscle builder, the focus was to create something that increases lung inspiration capacity to enable deeper breaths even when sitting, sleeping, and of course when doing even some mild physical activity, lungs would expand and contract like a motor, rapidfire speed.  Like if you pour very cold water suddenly, you’d feel lungs expanding and contracting like a dynamo. I didn’t even knew about hyperbaric therapy  BUT what I noted and those who have used it said 1. It improved their vision 2.  Better skin and younger looking face.  3. Muscle tone improvement and no fatigue on repeated movements.  4. Better urinary flow down to the last drop with high pressure like some piston inside. 5. Heart beating stronger. 6. Mind feeling enlightened.

Muscle growth formula works by sucking in oxygen by increasing lung expansion and contractions and efficient blood flow to tissues immediately as soon as they are absorbed and rapid speed circulation leading to fatigue free state 24/7 and a very healthy feeling.  All this is due to stem cell stimulation induced by efficient tweaking of the oxygen management.  Everyone breaths the same air, but you will use oxygen more than others.

Muscle builder is the only formula that always worked 100% in every person who ever used it. No other formula is as consistent and stable and always works only on a limited number of people. I have supplied Muscle builder to ladies as old as 73, 54, 59, and men aged 55 and up and all report same effect without fail.

Safety – In hyperbaric oxygen therapy, patients are placed in a hyperbaric chamber with higher air pressure than atmosphere for up to 90 minutes in a session to enable hyperoxygenation to the tissues breathing of pure oxygen.

Here in the Muscle builder we aren’t placing our bodies in any chamber but attaining same effect by encouraging higher lung inspiration capacity and rapidfire transfer of oxygen to all tissues 24 hours a day from a single ORAL dose.

So risk of pressurized chamber does not arise in this !

See risks of HBOT
http://archive.rubicon-foundation.org/xmlui/handle/123456789/2316

See this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RtW4iBtFqo about what Muscle builder can do with same effect as hyperbaric oxygen therapy. He also talks about bone forming cells stimulated by the therapy.

He also referenced an article from 1967 entitled “EFFECT OF HYPERBARIC OXYGENATION ON LONGITUDINAL GROWTH OF BONES” by BJORN MAURITZ PERSSO.

Click Here to Subscribe via iTunes and/or leave a review for the podcast!

  • Length of time: 30 mins
  • Beginning of actual interview: 1:15

Listen Here – (to download, right click and ‘save’)

Grow Taller and Increase Height using Intermittent Parathyroid Hormone Therapy to Increase Bone Formation

Something that I have wondered ever since I wrote the post about how I thought Parathyroid Hormone related Protein aka PTHrP was the thing that we were looking for, I have wondered how something like it should be administered.

The original post was “The Connection Between Regenerating Deer Antlers and The PTHrP, PTH And IHH pathway for Cartilage Regulation, PTHrP Seems To Be The Answer (Big Breakthrough!)”

Looking over the multiple studies on how much effect mechanical loading is towards actual bone remodeling and effects, I would say that anything that would be just a continuous steady state of injected compound would not work. Even increasing growth factor injection at a linear constant rate would not work. I am proposing that the way to make any technique or method work is to apply the stimuli in a non-constant, intermittent way where for only a short period of time each day or week do we try out a stimuli. This behavior of stimuli is going to work the best.

Two previous post link the idea of doing something intermittently as well.

The thing about the human body, like most biological bodies which have homeostasis, is that it is always pushing the body to a state of equilibrium. The elements in the body, which include the tissues, will develop often a resistance to any type of increased concentration, density, or flow of any type of foreign or outside stimuli.

A good example of this is what the neurotransmitter receptors in the axons of the neuron do when a person starts to take either a stimulant or relaxant and the receptor numbers eventually change in quantity and the overall neuron losses its sensitivity to the “drug”.

A 2nd example is how bodybuilders are trying to cycle through any type of supplement, peptide, or steroid use. The body just looses the sensitivity so the person can either try to increase the dosage risking side effects, or they drop the dosage waiting for the body to recover again, and go back to a state where it can be easily effected by ingested supplements again.

If we just applied 100 Nextons of force on a bone surface to make it grow harders, stronger, and thicken, at some point the bone will remodel itself to be able to withstand the force. If the bone can’t withstand the bone loading, it will just fracture and break apart. However, if the concentration or amount is not too high, the bones will eventually get harder and stronger.

So we can’t just increase bone loads or use growth factors in a continuous way. We have to choose very carefully a certain amount to be used. The therapy will consist of a rather high dose of PTHrP injected with a needle into the bone area close to the ends of our long bones.

The exact formation is to do 4 injects around the top area (epiphysis) of out lower leg, right below the knee protrusion region. The dosage I would say is around 100 micrograms/mL for each needle. Since there is 4 needles, each going into all 4 directions into the leg, there will be a total of 400 migrograms/mL beign injected. The rate of use will be 2 times a week.

The exact location I am proposing is the cortical bone layer just beneath the periosteum. It has to be subcutaneously, but also subperiosteal. The PTHrP has the ability to turn the cambium layer of progenitor bone cells possibly into chondrocytes and thus cartilage tissue. The result is that the hard material of the cortical bone might decrease leaving the area flexible enough to be pushed apart by the newly formed cartilage tissue.

The only problem with this idea is that we still would need a step or injected compound that can cause the hard cortical bone to weaken, de-ossify, decalcify for anything to work.

I guess the main thing to take away from this post is that any type of therapy used should be done in an intermittent fashion.

A Redesign On The LSJL, Bone Loading Device To Decrease Cost And Increase Efficacy

Months ago Tyler gave me a link to a patent which was proposed by Yokota for the loading device that was done to the lab mice’s synovial joints. When I saw how the researchers were actually loading the joints I realized that it is possible to simplify the loading machine to something similar. The patent name and link is below…

APPARATUS AND METHOD FOR ENHANCING BONE FORMATION (WO2005027735)

Let me say that patents are created to protect legal entities from other people stealing their ideas and profiting from them. If I was to build this device, then I would give this to Tyler or another LSJL experimenter for personal use. I don’t plan to sell the device.

This post is to state that I wanted to do a redesign of the old idea, which is to take two linear actuators, align them up, and the two ends of the actuators would push inward loading the synovial joints. Refer to the old picture I drew using Google Sketch Up.

lsjl device

Now look at the design that Yokota (with Tanaka) is proposing. It is much simpler in design because instead of two actuators or machines that is pushing down and up in a sinusoidal manner, there is actually just one lever that is moving up and down in a certain frequency.

lsjl 2

lsjl 1

lsjl 3


The idea is that we just use one movable piece loading on one side, and hold the other side of the synovial joint in place using a firm board or surface so that the joint can’t move as a result of being loaded.

The first picture is showing that we want to be loading the bones in the lateral direction from the axis direction of the long bones. The side of the epiphysis is being pushed down.

I am looking at the lever that is pushing down on the joint and I am questioning whether it is even necessary to making the loading mechanical. Would it just be simpler if we did it using human arm strength, pushing down on the metal piece that is doing the loading?

I used to design 3-D Objects using the Mechanical Engineering softwares Solidworks, 3DS MAX, and Autocad but it is still rather difficult for me to figure out what exactly the design should look like in a 3-D way.

The writing on the patent is extremely hard for me to read. It seems to say that the bottom part is a piezo-actuator, which makes sense. The bones themselves have piezoelectric properties.

When the level is pressed down on the bone, I am guessing that the circuit is fully closed, leading to a small amount of current being run through the device, giving a slight electrical signal to the bone/epiphysis of the loaded area. This might be what Yokota means when he is saying that the bones as piezo-electric material will react in some way to remodel themselves form the electrical signal.

However using the Google SketchUp, since it is free and I don’t have a Solidworks or AutoCad license anymore, I have only been able to so far in the simplified design. I can not go any farther since I don’t exactly know what I am seeing or reading. The 3-D design I have posted below is all that I can do. It will eventually save money at least for the initial cost of the building of say the first prototype. LSJL sketch 2LSJL sketch

Increase Height And Grow Taller Through Bioprinting And Electrospinning

A big idea that is going around regenerative medicine circles now with the 3-D Printers that have been coming out is the idea of printing one’s own organs and body parts for use in transplantation.

The idea of bioprinting and electrospinning has been getting bigger and bigger in the last 2 years. What I am proposing in the year 2013 is that one day within the next 30 years we will be able to take a small cartilage or pluripotent stem cell sample from a person and be able to completely create a good sized growth plate completely regenerated for a person ready to be implanted.

This would result in people being able to choose to regrow again making them taller and taller.

When I typed in the phrase “Bioprinting” into Google the first result they gave me was of a company named Organovo, which has a tagline of “CHANGING THE SHAPE OF MEDICAL RESEARCH AND PRACTICE”. From their front page…

Organovo creates living, three-dimensional human tissue models for research and therapeutic applications

The flexibility of our bioprinting technology, which marries biology and engineering, and its proven application across a wide variety of cells, allows us to target many different tissues for development of human tissue models.

We are currently building a number of 3D tissue models for research and drug discovery applications, and well as working to fulfill our vision of building human tissues for surgical therapy and transplantation.

Under the Therapeutic Tissues section…

3D Human Therapeutic Tissues – At Organovo, we believe that engineered tissues will someday be a routine source of therapy for patients with damaged or diseased tissue.

Changing the Shape of Medical Practice – Organovo is working to fulfill the vision of building human tissues for advanced surgical therapy and transplantation.

Today, we are working, both internally and with select partners, to fulfill our vision of building human tissues for surgical therapy and transplantation. The flexibility of our tissue engineering technology, and its proven application across a wide variety of cells, allows us to target many different tissues. The cell source can be either allogenic or autologous (using the patient’s own cells), which could allow us to avoid transplant rejection and the need for life-long immunosuppresant drugs.

Significant science and discovery is required to develop a tissue therapy, ensure safety and efficacy through controlled clinical trials, and gain regulatory clearance as a medical device. Supplemental tissue therapies that could come in forms of tubes, patches, or organoids are a developmental possibility today. Larger replacement tissues remains a future goal; however, the insight gained through the development of supplemental tissue therapies can serve as key guideposts for the ultimate development of functional organ replacements.

The promise for tissue therapies that cure disease, with reduced risk of immune rejection, made on demand from cellular building blocks rather than waiting for a limited supply of donor tissues, is a vision we are passionate in pursuing.

I showed in a recent post that university researchers have been able to grow a growing bone with it’s epiphyseal growth plate cartilage being completely functional. This shows that by combining the fields of stem cell therapy and tissue engineering, the growth plate can be regrown using the initial stem cells, an external growth factor stimuli, and a scaffold to hold the two main parts in place ready for implantation. This company Organovo has the potential to make a real big change in the way physicians and surgeons have been practicing medicine.

Just like how the inventor Eli Whitney managed to create the idea of Interchangeable parts for machines and guns leading to the revolution of factories, specialization, systems, automation, and mass production of everything becoming one of the main causes of the Industrial Revolution, this new technology of being able to print in 3-D the tissue and organs we will need means that maybe one day humans will be looked as less as a single entitle but as a combination of organ systems which can be kept alive by just replacing the parts that go bad, old, or not working.

From the section on Bioprinted Human Tissue

Organovo’s proprietary bioprinting platform captures the unique synergistic potential of engineering and biology to enable the reproducible, automated creation of living human tissues that mimic the form and function of native tissues in the body. Our 3D bioprinted human tissues are constructed with precision from tiny building blocks made of living human cells, using a processthat translates tissue-specific geometries and cellular components into 3D designs that can be executed by an Organovo NovoGen Bioprinter™. Once built, the bioprinted tissues share many key features with native tissue, including tissue-like cellular density, presence of multiple cell types, and the development of key architectural and functional features associated with the target native tissue.

Organovo’s 3D human tissues offer many advantages over standard cell-culture platforms due to the fact that three-dimensionality is achieved without dependence on biomaterial or scaffold components that would not be found in native tissues.

We are not immortals and we are not superheros like Superman and Wolverine. Gods have bodies that don’t age or get ill. Superman has the power to be invulnerable against everything except Kyptonite. Wolverine can be hurt and injured but his body has insane cells which can heal any wound within minutes, if not seconds. Maybe one day we can develop soem type of technology, where all we have to do is take a gun with some medical light and shine it on a part of our body to solve all medical problems. Before that can come to be, the next best thing is the idea of having the ability to grow our own body parts, for fast surgery transplantations? Need a new liver, kidney, or pancreas? Let’s grow that for you in the lab?

For our situation, we don’t have any more growth plates so what do we do? We extract a little bit of cartilage and chondrocytes, and grow them into adult sized growth plate cartilages and transplant them into the leg. That means that we can start the longitudinal growth of the bones again.

Here is a video below of one of the founders of the company Gabor Forgacs who is giving a TEDTalk about his company’s technology.

For a better read on the subject of bioprinting refer to the article from a website called Explaining The Future

I would also like to the refer the reader who is mainly interested in using this technology for the cosmetic reason of potentially increasing their height this picture I found from another source/ article talking about the exploding, new hot biomedical field of 3-D Bioprinting research. Refer to the picture below. Notice that the picture on the researchers from Wake Forest University shows that they have been able to recreate the outer ear. That is cartilage. This shows that scientists have already been able to create cartilage nearly from scratch by using the bioprinting machines.

Screen Shot 2013-06-08 at 7.52.38 PM

Using Acids To Induce Reverse Ossification For Calcium Mineral Absorption

A little well known idea that I did not know about is from a grade school science project may give a proposed idea on how to reverse the bone ossification process to make the bones much more flexible and elastic for tensile loading leading to plastic deformation.

It involves the idea that if you take normal dried up bone (like from a cadaver) and put it into a vinegar solution the bones will actually eventually become like a hard rubber material.

Implications For Height Increase:

I think at this point in the research it is critical that we figure out some way to make the bones easier to bend and stretch. The idea of soaking bones in acid to de-calcify them is a very interesting proposal for bone lengthening later.

From source #2, it seems that vinegar like most acids can dissolve the calcium crystals from insoluble into soluble. The chemical reaction that is shown is….

CaCO3 + 2CH3COO -> Ca(CH3COO)2 + H2O +CO2

From Source #2: Once paired with vinegar, the calcium takes on the form of calcium acetate, which is soluble, so the calcium is absorbed and able to be utilized by bone.

A second, lesser known reason, is that the main acid in vinegar, acetic acid, lowers the amount of phosphorus the body can absorb. Phosphorus is a strong acid from meats and beans and grains unlike the weak acid of vinegar. Normally a certain amount of calcium will cleave to a certain amount of phosphorus and they will cancel each other out. When vinegar gets involved, less calcium is needed to cancel out a greater proportion of phosphorus and therefore less phosphorus is absorbed. If too much phosphorus came through, calcium would have been taken from bone to neutralize it….This is one of the reasons a children’s bones grow so rapidly. Children have a high ratio of good bacteria in their colon that synthesize acetic, as well as lactic, and other acids from the fiber or lactose that is eaten. As we grow older we don’t eat the right foods to support these guys. On a side note, that is one of the reasons Honey is good for bones as well. It specifically feeds these guys and keeps them cranking out acetic acid….Finally, while an acid, vinegar is like fruit in that the end product is not an acid at all. Once all of these reactions take place, the end products as you can see above are water and CO2. We breath out the CO2 into the air and end up with a net positive of base.

Analysis: I don’t remember my organic chemistry studies that well but I will take a crack at the logic behind the answer given by this guy.

First, he made a mistake on the 2nd compound, which is supposed to be ascetic acid. All acids have a O-O-H ending, so the right answer to balance both sides of the chemical reaction accounting for each element is to change the CH3OO into CH3OOH.

2nd, the guy is saying that the ascetic acid will lower the amount of phosphorous the body will absorb. However we know that the calcium is combining with the phosphorous in the human’s body to make the calcium phosphate minerals. I also assume that when the speaker is talking about the body, they are talking about the blood stream. If the ascetic acid is indeed somehow lowering the amount of phosphate the body is absorbing, then there would be more phosphorous being pushed out of the blood stream, and ending up in the bone matrix. If this is happening, then I would say that the bones would actually be getting stronger. More phosphorous, meaning more calcium phosphates, which are the hydroxyapatite, means the bones should get stronger and tougher, not the other way around.

He is right that the calcium cleaves to a phosphorous, but they don’t actually cancel each other out. The calcium somehow binds to the phosphorous forming a stable hard mineral. If that is what the guys means by  “canceling each other out” then okay, that makes some sense.

The thing is that we do need phosphorous to make the bones hard. Maybe what the guy means is that the ascetic acid is keeping the phosphorous from binding to the calcium. If that is what the guy means, then that would make sense. the phosphorous can’t join together with the calcium to make the hard minerals, making the bones softer. However, all of this is assuming that when he is talking about phosphorous absorption, he is not referring to the blood which is what I assumed in the beginning, but actually by the calcium element.

From source #3: The acetic acid of the vinegar will dissolve the calcium carbonate in the bones.

Analysis: It is interesting that again the people who are answering the question about how vinegar can rubberize bones keep saying that it is calcium carbonate that is reacting with the ascetic acid. However I am guess that it is the calcium phosphates that are the real reagent here. Let’s remember what we learned about the real calcium minerals that make the bones hard. It is the hydroxyapatites, calcium phosphates. Source 3 is good in showing that there is actually two main components that give the bones their hardness…

1. the collagenous material that gives the bones high tensile strength and make them flexible.

2. the calcium based mineral crystals which are inorganic, non living that is embedded all throughout the bone extracellular matrix. The calcium minerals gives the bones an extremely high compressive strength.

  • So calcium carbonate is… Ca5(PO4)3(OH
  • and calcium phosphate is… Ca5(PO4)3(OH 

So my real question is what is the ascetic acid of the vinegar really reacting to? and also, what is really giving the bones their hardness and strength?

The people who are giving answers on how vinegar can de-ossify say that the CH3OOH is reacting with calcium carbonate, but I am guessing that the real calcium mineral the acid is reacting with is calcium phosphate. The calcium mineral is obviously being broken down/dissolved by the acid in some way.

In the end, we could just say that from elementary grade school science projects, the bones do indeed lose their hardness and strength becoming almost elastic. This is what is important.

We have a very cheap, read at hand way to possibly de-ossify the bones to a level of elasticity where stretching the bones becomes a possibility.

So is there something that I can propose right now like a easy to make device we can put around our leg bone to make them softer for stretching? I don’t have anything right now but it should not be that hard to create a device we can either stick, glue, or embed to the surface of a bone to make it weaker. The fact is that the upper/proximal epiphysis of our tibia is right by the skin.

A band with vinegar inside which we can insert through the skin to the bones will be easy thing to invent.